Offering online therapy in Texas, New Hampshire, Florida & South Carolina
abs-logo-blue
  • List Item #1
  • List Item #2

Why Trauma Can Make Trust Feel Physically Impossible

Trauma and Trust

How to Support Your Nervous System in Regaining a Sense of Safety

If you’ve ever thought:
  • “I want to trust people… but I just can’t.”
  • “My body shuts down when someone gets too close.”
  • “I know they’re safe, yet something inside me doesn’t believe it.”
You are not alone; your response makes sense.
After trauma, trust involves more than the mind—it’s connected to your nervous system.
As a trauma therapist in Conroe, Texas, I often tell clients this:
Trust is not a decision you make with your thoughts. It is a state your body must feel.
After trauma, the body often does not feel safe.

Trauma Is Stored in the Body as Well as the Mind

Trauma isn’t only about what happened. It’s about what your nervous system learned.
When something overwhelming, frightening, or violating occurs, your brain shifts into survival mode. The amygdala (your threat detector) activates. Stress hormones surge. Your body prepares to fight, flee, freeze, or fawn.
If the event was overwhelming, occurred too quickly, or was experienced in isolation, the nervous system may not fully reset.
This is why, years later, you might notice:
  • Tightness in your chest when someone expresses love
  • A pit in your stomach when someone asks you to depend on them
  • Sudden irritability or shutdown during conflict
  • Numbness when emotional intimacy increases
Your body is not overreacting.
It’s being protective.

Why Trust May Feel Physically Unsafe After Trauma

Trust requires vulnerability. Vulnerability requires safety.
If your history includes betrayal, abandonment, emotional neglect, abuse, or chaotic relationships, your nervous system may have learned:
Closeness is perceived as danger.
As connection increases, your body may respond as if a threat is present, even when you logically know you are safe.
Common physical responses include:
  • Increased heart rate
  • Shallow breathing
  • Muscle tension
  • Brain fog
  • Sudden affective numbness
  • Urge to withdraw or push away.
This response isn’t a flaw; it’s survival.
It is a survival response.
For many adults in Montgomery County, The Woodlands, Willis, and Conroe, TX, this shows up in marriages, dating relationships, friendships, and even work relationships.
You may deeply want connection, yet feel physically unable to tolerate it.
This internal conflict can be exhausting.

The Nervous System and the ‘Threat-Focused’ Brain

When trauma remains unresolved, the brain can become what I often call “threat-focused.”
Instead of scanning for connection, it scans for danger.
Small cues, such as a delayed text message, a change in tone, or constructive feedback, can trigger a full-body alarm response.
Your body may react before you even consciously understand why.
This is especially common in persons struggling with:
  • PTSD
  • Anxiety disorders
  • Childhood trauma
  • Attachment wounds
  • High-conflict divorces
  • Chronic stress or breakdown
In these cases, trust may feel physically impossible because your nervous system equates trust with vulnerability, and vulnerability with risk.

Why ‘Just Think Positive’ Does Not Work

Many people try to fix trust issues cognitively.
  • They read self-help books.
  • They repeat affirmations.
  • They try to “be more logical.”
However, trauma resides in the subcortical brain, below conscious thought. your body out of a survival response.
This is why trauma-informed therapy approaches are essential.
At Authentic Brain Solutions in Conroe, Texas, I integrate brain-based therapies that work with the nervous system rather than against it.
Healing trust is not about forcing yourself to feel safe.
It’s about helping your brain and body actually experience safety.

How EMDR Therapy Helps Rewire Trust Responses

Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) is one of the most effective treatments for trauma.
Rather than only talking about painful memories, EMDR involves specific techniques to help your brain process trauma. The aim is for your brain to understand the past event as something that happened, not something that’s still dangerous now.
When trauma is reprocessed:
  • The body no longer reacts as if the event is happening now.
  • Triggers lose intensity
  • Emotions feel proportional
  • Trust becomes less activating.
As a Certified EMDR Therapist serving clients in Conroe, The Woodlands, Montgomery, and via telehealth across Texas, Florida, South Carolina, and New Hampshire, I have seen how powerful this change can be.
Clients often say,
“It doesn’t feel charged anymore.”
or
“I can think about it without my body reacting.”
This is the moment when trust begins to feel possible again. Neurofeedback Supports Trauma Recovery
Neurofeedback, including IASIS Microcurrent Neurofeedback, involves using technology to measure your brain activity and provide feedback. This feedback can help your brain learn to calm down from constant fight-or-flight responses caused by trauma.
Neurofeedback helps the brain shift out of chronic fight-or-flight activation.
When the brain is less reactive:
  • Emotional intensity decreases
  • Sleep improves
  • Irritability reduces
  • The body feels calmer in relationships.
Many clients describe it as their brain finally “getting a deep breath.”
When your nervous system is calmer, trust no longer feels overwhelming.
It becomes manageable.

The Role of Attachment and Early Experiences

Trust issues are not always linked to one major traumatic event.
Sometimes they develop from:
  • Inconsistent caregiving
  • Emotional neglect
  • Growing up in a high-conflict home
  • Chronic unpredictability
  • Being the ‘strong one’ who could not show vulnerability
If closeness was unreliable in childhood, your nervous system may have adjusted by becoming hyper-independent.
Independence may appear strong externally.
Internally, however, it can feel lonely.
Healing trust involves gradually teaching your nervous system that connection is no longer associated with danger.
That process takes patience, safety, and the right therapeutic support.

Signs Your Body May Be Blocking Trust

You may notice:
  • You pull away when someone gets emotionally close.
  • You overanalyze texts and conversations.
  • You assume people will eventually leave.
  • You feel numb instead of connected.
  • You experience a sudden shutdown during intimacy.
  • You may sabotage relationships when they feel ‘too good’
These are not signs that you are broken.
They are signs your nervous system is protecting you.
And protection made sense at one time.
Now, your nervous system may simply need to adapt.

Trauma Therapy in Conroe, TX:

Renewing Trust From the Inside Out

Healing trust is not about becoming naive.
It’s about helping your brain distinguish past from present safety.
At Authentic Brain Solutions, I integrate:
  • EMDR therapy
  • IASIS Microcurrent Neurofeedback
  • Neurocounseling approaches
  • Mindfulness and nervous system regulation strategies
My office in Conroe, TX, serves individuals from:
And I provide virtual health services across Texas, Florida, South Carolina, and New Hampshire.
If trust feels physically impossible right now, it does not mean it will always feel this way.
Your nervous system learned to protect you.
It can also learn to feel safe again.

What Healing Often Feels Like

Healing trust rarely happens overnight.
But clients often notice gradual shifts:
  • Less body tension during hard conversations
  • Increased ability to stay present
  • More emotional flexibility
  • Reduced fear of abandonment
  • Greater clarity in relationships
Instead of feeling hijacked by survival responses, you begin responding from choice.
This is when trust shifts from feeling impossible, to guarded, and eventually to possible.

You Are Not Broken; Your Nervous System Has Adapted

If trauma has made trust feel physically impossible, please know:
Your body is not working against you.
It is working for your survival.
With the right support, your nervous system can learn new patterns.
Safety.
Connection.
Trust.

Next Steps

Take the next step—schedule your free 15-minute consultation for trauma therapy in Conroe, TX, or via telehealth today and see if we’re the right fit for your needs.

 

Schedule your session here:

➡️ https://authenticbrainsolutions.com/contact/

Serving clients in:

Conroe • Montgomery • The Woodlands • Willis • Lake Conroe Area • Telehealth Across Texas

 

Follow Authentic Brain Solutions:

“Trust isn’t rebuilt by forcing yourself to feel safe. It’s rebuilt when your nervous system finally learns that the danger is over. ” Eileen Borski, LPC

📍 Office: 96 Beach Walk Blvd., Suite 201-A, Conroe, TX

🌐 Website: https://authenticbrainsolutions.com

Contact Us
abs-logo-blue